Pettey to spend rest of life in prison after guilty verdict - Quincy Herald-Whig | Illinois & Missouri News, Sports

Pettey to spend rest of life in prison after guilty verdict

Posted: Updated:
Kimberly Young, front left in blue, the younger sister of Sandra Fugate, holds back the tears as Calvin Duane Pettey was found guilty of first degree murder. To the right of Young is Mary Patterson, Fugate's mother. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson) Kimberly Young, front left in blue, the younger sister of Sandra Fugate, holds back the tears as Calvin Duane Pettey was found guilty of first degree murder. To the right of Young is Mary Patterson, Fugate's mother. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson)
Calvin Duane Pettey, in light blue, appears to bow his head in prayer before the verdict is read Wednesday. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson) Calvin Duane Pettey, in light blue, appears to bow his head in prayer before the verdict is read Wednesday. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson)
Marion County Prosecutor Tom Redington, center, casts a steely glare at Calvin Duane Pettey immediately after Pettey was found guilty in the 2010 death of Sandra Fugate Wednesday afternoon in the Audrain County Courthouse. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson) Marion County Prosecutor Tom Redington, center, casts a steely glare at Calvin Duane Pettey immediately after Pettey was found guilty in the 2010 death of Sandra Fugate Wednesday afternoon in the Audrain County Courthouse. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson)
Kimberly Young, left, younger sister of Sandra Fugate, comforts Mary Patterson, Fugate's mother, after the guilty verdict was read. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson) Kimberly Young, left, younger sister of Sandra Fugate, comforts Mary Patterson, Fugate's mother, after the guilty verdict was read. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson)
Mary Patterson, the mother of Sandra Fugate, keeps a tight grip on Fugate's youngest sister, Kimberly Young, front center, who glares at Calvin Duate Pettey as Pettey was led out of the courtroom. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson) Mary Patterson, the mother of Sandra Fugate, keeps a tight grip on Fugate's youngest sister, Kimberly Young, front center, who glares at Calvin Duate Pettey as Pettey was led out of the courtroom. (H-W Photo/Phil Carlson)

By RODNEY HART
Herald-Whig Staff Writer

MEXICO, Mo. — An Audrain County jury deliberated for a little more than three hours Wednesday before finding Calvin Duane Pettey guilty of murdering fiancée Sandra Fugate in her Hannibal home more than two years ago.

Members of Fugate's family and friends cried and raised fists when Judge Keith Sutherland read the verdict in the Audrain County Courthouse. The 42-year-old Pettey, who will be sentenced Aug. 27 to life in prison by Sutherland, showed little emotion when the verdict was read.

Fugate's mother, Mary Patterson, hugged friends and family outside the courthouse after Pettey was led away. He will be lodged in the Marion County Jail until sentencing. Life in prison without parole is the mandatory sentence for first-degree murder in Missouri.

"I just want to know why he did it," said Patterson, who testified about finding her daughter's body in the basement of Fugate's home on Iowa Street in Hannibal on April 15, 2010. "Why didn't he just leave her?"

Key trial testimony came Tuesday morning from Rebecca Kirk, who said she and Pettey were lovers and plotted to kill Fugate because he didn't want to go through with their planned wedding on April 17, 2010. Kirk said she could not go through with several murder plans, although she did dispose of evidence and never told police or Fugate about the plot.

"She (Kirk) is just as guilty as he is," Patterson said. "Her day will come."

Marion County Prosecutor Tom Redington said he was "pleased" with the trial outcome, but did not say if Kirk will be charged. The statute of limitations is three years.

"You will just have to wait and see," said Redington.

Defense attorney Todd Schulze declined to comment when leaving the courtroom.

Patterson said friends and family have helped her get through "hell" since her daughter was murdered.

"They've all been with me from day one," she said through tears.

A group of women calling themselves "Sandy's Sisterhood" said Fugate was "finally as peace." One of them yelled "Guilty!" as they stood outside the courthouse on a warm summer day.

The trial lasted three days, and featured about 70 exhibits and 27 witnesses.

—  rhart@whig.com/221-3370

  • Local HeadlinesLocal HeadlinesMore>>

  • Volunteers respond to report of theft to build new wheelchair ramp for veteran

    Volunteers respond to report of theft to build new wheelchair ramp for veteran

    Monday, October 20 2014 12:58 AM EDT2014-10-20 04:58:50 GMT
    Roger Rupp was incredulous when he learned his wheelchair ramp had been taken from his home two weeks ago. Rupp, a U.S. Army veteran, has multiple sclerosis. The 10-foot by 3-foot aluminum ramp helped him access a garage at the rear of his 11th Street house -- or at least it did. Quincy Police say the ramp and two handrails were swiped sometime between Oct. 5 and 6. "I really couldn't believe it," Rupp said. Neither could a group of local volunteers. After hearing about the ramp's ...
    Roger Rupp was incredulous when he learned his wheelchair ramp had been taken from his home two weeks ago. Rupp, a U.S. Army veteran, has multiple sclerosis. The 10-foot by 3-foot aluminum ramp helped him access a garage at the rear of his 11th Street house -- or at least it did. Quincy Police say the ramp and two handrails were swiped sometime between Oct. 5 and 6. "I really couldn't believe it," Rupp said. Neither could a group of local volunteers. After hearing about the ramp's ...
  • Warsaw man stabbed after argument with man he had been fishing with

    Warsaw man stabbed after argument with man he had been fishing with

    Tuesday, October 21 2014 11:20 AM EDT2014-10-21 15:20:32 GMT
    WARSAW, Ill. — An arrest was made early Tuesday morning in connection to a stabbing Monday night of a 40-year-old Warsaw man at a home at 10th and Crawford.Dorrance Smysor, 67, of Elmwood was arrested at 5 a.m. Tuesday in Elmwood by an officer with Warsaw Police Department and a Hancock County Sheriff's Department deputy. Smysor is lodged in the Hancock County Jail.Brial Cleer was airlifted from the scene to Blessing Hospital in Quincy for treatment of multiple stab wounds, according to polic...
    WARSAW, Ill. — An arrest was made early Tuesday morning in connection to a stabbing Monday night of a 40-year-old Warsaw man at a home at 10th and Crawford.Dorrance Smysor, 67, of Elmwood was arrested at 5 a.m. Tuesday in Elmwood by an officer with Warsaw Police Department and a Hancock County Sheriff's Department deputy. Smysor is lodged in the Hancock County Jail.Brial Cleer was airlifted from the scene to Blessing Hospital in Quincy for treatment of multiple stab wounds, according to polic...
  • UPDATE: Body discovered in Mississippi River believed to be missing tugboat worker

    UPDATE: Body discovered in Mississippi River believed to be missing tugboat worker

    Tuesday, October 21 2014 10:38 AM EDT2014-10-21 14:38:35 GMT
    A body pulled from the Mississippi River near LaGrange, Mo., Monday afternoon is believed to be a missing 22-year-old man who fell off a tugboat Oct. 8, said Adams County Coroner Jim Keller.
    A body pulled from the Mississippi River near LaGrange, Mo., Monday afternoon is believed to be a missing 22-year-old man who fell off a tugboat Oct. 8, said Adams County Coroner Jim Keller.
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and Quincy Herald-Whig. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service and Mobile Privacy Policy & Terms of Service.